Talk:Cello - Revision history

imported>Ryangibsonstewart: /* Rename to Emma's cello */

2010-02-13T21:54:20Z

Rename to Emma's cello

← Older revision	Revision as of 21:54, 13 February 2010
(No difference)

imported>Ryangibsonstewart: /* Rename to Emma's cello */

2010-02-13T21:54:20Z

Rename to Emma's cello

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:54, 13 February 2010
Line 14:		Line 14:
	******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)		******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)
	******** I think the article is for all cellos in the series, not just Emma's.--[[User:PJDEP\|PJDEP]] - [[User Talk:PJDEP\|Need further explanation?]] 16:00, 13 February 2010 (EST)		******** I think the article is for all cellos in the series, not just Emma's.--[[User:PJDEP\|PJDEP]] - [[User Talk:PJDEP\|Need further explanation?]] 16:00, 13 February 2010 (EST)
			********* The category shouldn't be there, though. We don't know if the cello was Bob's personal cello, or if it was ever used for "Company purposes". Until we find that out, we shouldn't add the category to this page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 16:54, 13 February 2010 (EST)

imported>PJDEP: /* Rename to Emma's cello */

2010-02-13T21:00:18Z

Rename to Emma's cello

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:00, 13 February 2010
Line 13:		Line 13:
	****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)		****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)		******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)
			******** I think the article is for all cellos in the series, not just Emma's.--[[User:PJDEP\|PJDEP]] - [[User Talk:PJDEP\|Need further explanation?]] 16:00, 13 February 2010 (EST)

imported>Juba: the same?

2010-02-13T18:46:25Z

the same?

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:46, 13 February 2010
Line 12:		Line 12:
	***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)		***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)		****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)
			******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)

imported>Referos: /* Rename to Emma's cello */

2010-01-17T02:34:06Z

Rename to Emma's cello

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:34, 17 January 2010
Line 11:		Line 11:
	**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)		**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)		***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by Emma's cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)		****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)

imported>Referos: /* Rename to Emma's cello */

2010-01-17T02:32:32Z

Rename to Emma's cello

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:32, 17 January 2010
Line 11:		Line 11:
	**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)		**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)		***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)
			****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by Emma's cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)

imported>Ryangibsonstewart at 02:09, 17 January 2010

2010-01-17T02:09:05Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:09, 17 January 2010
Line 10:		Line 10:
	*** I had forgotten about Vanessa's cello. I think that's a better idea.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 20:57, 16 January 2010 (EST)		*** I had forgotten about Vanessa's cello. I think that's a better idea.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 20:57, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)		**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)
			***** There's plenty of room to include information about all the cellos on this page. There's not room to include all the information about Lydia's tattoos on the [[tattoo]] page. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 21:09, 16 January 2010 (EST)

imported>Referos at 02:01, 17 January 2010

2010-01-17T02:01:50Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 02:01, 17 January 2010
Line 9:		Line 9:
	** I'd rather include information about [[Vanessa]]'s cello and simply keep this article about cellos in general. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 20:37, 16 January 2010 (EST)		** I'd rather include information about [[Vanessa]]'s cello and simply keep this article about cellos in general. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 20:37, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	*** I had forgotten about Vanessa's cello. I think that's a better idea.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 20:57, 16 January 2010 (EST)		*** I had forgotten about Vanessa's cello. I think that's a better idea.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 20:57, 16 January 2010 (EST)
			**** I disagree. [[Vanessa]]'s cello, [[Bob]]'s cello and that [[cellist\|guy]]'s cello, as far as we know, are just other cellos that are inconsequential to the plot. [[Emma]]'s cello is much more significant: it seems to be the trigger for an entire possible future since Peter thought that said future could be averted by destroying it. Due to its importance, which was acknowledged by both Angela and Peter, it deserves its own page. The situation, I think, is similar to how we have an article specifically to [[Lydia's tattoos]] (which play an important role in the plot) instead of just adding it to the generic [[tattoos]] page. If, for instance, Vanessa's cello turns out to be significant, then it can get its own page as well, similar as to how [[Lydia's tattoos]] and [[Jessica's tattoo]] are kept separate.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:01, 16 January 2010 (EST)

imported>MiamiVolts: /* Rename to Emma's cello */ reply

2010-01-17T01:57:46Z

Rename to Emma's cello: reply

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:57, 17 January 2010
Line 8:		Line 8:
	* Agreed, though if in the future Emma has another cello at the carnival, we should probably call it 'Emma's cellos'.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 19:51, 16 January 2010 (EST)		* Agreed, though if in the future Emma has another cello at the carnival, we should probably call it 'Emma's cellos'.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 19:51, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	** I'd rather include information about [[Vanessa]]'s cello and simply keep this article about cellos in general. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 20:37, 16 January 2010 (EST)		** I'd rather include information about [[Vanessa]]'s cello and simply keep this article about cellos in general. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 20:37, 16 January 2010 (EST)
			*** I had forgotten about Vanessa's cello. I think that's a better idea.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 20:57, 16 January 2010 (EST)

imported>Ryangibsonstewart: /* Rename to Emma's cello */

2010-01-17T01:37:14Z

Rename to Emma's cello

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:37, 17 January 2010
Line 7:		Line 7:
	The way the page is structured right now seems more like it's about references to cellos in general than an actual item. Given that Emma's cello is the only significant cello in ''Heroes'' and seems to play a crucial role in the future Peter dreamt, I think this page should be only about this particular cello. The fact that other characters have other cellos is just trivia, which could be added to the notes.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 19:48, 16 January 2010 (EST)		The way the page is structured right now seems more like it's about references to cellos in general than an actual item. Given that Emma's cello is the only significant cello in ''Heroes'' and seems to play a crucial role in the future Peter dreamt, I think this page should be only about this particular cello. The fact that other characters have other cellos is just trivia, which could be added to the notes.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 19:48, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	* Agreed, though if in the future Emma has another cello at the carnival, we should probably call it 'Emma's cellos'.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 19:51, 16 January 2010 (EST)		* Agreed, though if in the future Emma has another cello at the carnival, we should probably call it 'Emma's cellos'.--[[User:MiamiVolts\|MiamiVolts]] ([[User_talk:MiamiVolts\|talk]]) 19:51, 16 January 2010 (EST)
			** I'd rather include information about [[Vanessa]]'s cello and simply keep this article about cellos in general. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 20:37, 16 January 2010 (EST)

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:00, 13 February 2010
Line 13:		Line 13:
	****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)		****** I don't think there's space to include various cellos in this page. I don't mean "physical" space as in "the page would get too big". We've got Emma's cello, how it was meant for Vanessa, how Emma got it, its relation to Emma's power, how it seems to trigger a terrible future, and its current status. This is crucial to the plot and should obviously appear in the page. All the other references to cellos -- which are just "Vanessa has a cello", "Bob has a cello" and "A cellist has a cello" -- are insignificant, irrelevant and distracting. A simple note about how three other people also have cellos is more than enough, leaving space so that the reader can easily follow the role played by ''Emma's'' cello.--[[User:Referos\|Referos]] 21:32, 16 January 2010 (EST)
	******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)		******* I have to say coming from Emma you are surprised to read Category:The Company! What, Samuel got Bob's Cello?! --[[User:Juba\|Juba]] 13:46, 13 February 2010 (EST)
			******** I think the article is for all cellos in the series, not just Emma's.--[[User:PJDEP\|PJDEP]] - [[User Talk:PJDEP\|Need further explanation?]] 16:00, 13 February 2010 (EST)