User:SacValleyDweller/Artist grades - Revision history

imported>SacValleyDweller: alpha

2009-12-22T05:48:24Z

alpha

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:48, 22 December 2009
(No difference)

imported>SacValleyDweller: alpha

2009-12-22T05:48:24Z

alpha

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:48, 22 December 2009
Line 12:		Line 12:
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B + \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips		\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B + \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips
⚫	\|-
⚫	\| [[Luis Puig]] \|\| B \|\| none
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight		\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight
Line 24:		Line 22:
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Siya Oum]] \|\| B \|\| {{note}} Art is like oil paintings		\| [[Siya Oum]] \|\| B \|\| {{note}} Art is like oil paintings
		⚫	\|-
		⚫	\| [[Luis Puig]] \|\| B \|\| none
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}} [[Angie]], and [[Anna]], and [[Sheila]] nicely drawn in their respective GNs		\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}} [[Angie]], and [[Anna]], and [[Sheila]] nicely drawn in their respective GNs

imported>SacValleyDweller: add new artist

2009-12-22T05:47:40Z

add new artist

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:47, 22 December 2009
Line 11:		Line 11:
	\| [[Michael Gaydos]] \|\| A \|\| {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well		\| [[Michael Gaydos]] \|\| A \|\| {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips		\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B + \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips
			\|-
			\| [[Luis Puig]] \|\| B \|\| none
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight		\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */

2009-05-26T05:38:08Z

Artist grades

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:38, 26 May 2009
Line 23:		Line 23:
	\| [[Siya Oum]] \|\| B \|\| {{note}} Art is like oil paintings		\| [[Siya Oum]] \|\| B \|\| {{note}} Art is like oil paintings
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}} [[Angie]], and [[Anna]], and [[~~Shela~~]] nicely drawn in their respective GNs		\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}} [[Angie]], and [[Anna]], and [[Sheila]] nicely drawn in their respective GNs
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Phil Jimenez]] \|\| C+ \|\| none		\| [[Phil Jimenez]] \|\| C+ \|\| none

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */ Add newest three artists

2009-05-26T05:36:36Z

Artist grades: Add newest three artists

← Older revision		Revision as of 05:36, 26 May 2009
Line 21:		Line 21:
	\| [[Alitha Martinez]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Largely soft and smooth <br> {{plus}} Art sparkles a little <br /> {{minus}} Flat faces in profile shots at times <br /> {{minus}} Slight babyface-ness		\| [[Alitha Martinez]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Largely soft and smooth <br> {{plus}} Art sparkles a little <br /> {{minus}} Flat faces in profile shots at times <br /> {{minus}} Slight babyface-ness
	\|-		\|-
			\| [[Siya Oum]] \|\| B \|\| {{note}} Art is like oil paintings
⚫	\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}}~~Nice~~ ~~rendering~~ of [[Anna]] in ''[[~~Red~~ ~~Eye~~ ~~(disambig)\|Red~~ ~~Eye]]''~~
			\|-
		⚫	\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}} [[Angie]], and [[Anna]], and [[Shela]] nicely drawn in their respective GNs
			\|-
			\| [[Phil Jimenez]] \|\| C+ \|\| none
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Ryan Odagawa]] \|\| C+ \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean		\| [[Ryan Odagawa]] \|\| C+ \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean
Line 34:		Line 38:
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[ChrisCross]] \|\| D \|\| {{minus}} Poor likenesses		\| [[ChrisCross]] \|\| D \|\| {{minus}} Poor likenesses
			\|-
			\| [[Greg Beeman]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor likenesses <br /> {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Steven Lejeune]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses		\| [[Steven Lejeune]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */

2009-02-17T01:59:32Z

Artist grades

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:59, 17 February 2009
Line 33:		Line 33:
	\| [[Peter Steigerwald]] \|\| C- \|\| {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times		\| [[Peter Steigerwald]] \|\| C- \|\| {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[~~CrissCross~~]] \|\| D \|\| {{minus}} Poor likenesses		\| [[ChrisCross]] \|\| D \|\| {{minus}} Poor likenesses
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Steven Lejeune]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses		\| [[Steven Lejeune]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */ Add an artist

2009-02-17T01:58:13Z

Artist grades: Add an artist

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:58, 17 February 2009
Line 32:		Line 32:
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Peter Steigerwald]] \|\| C- \|\| {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times		\| [[Peter Steigerwald]] \|\| C- \|\| {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times
			\|-
			\| [[CrissCross]] \|\| D \|\| {{minus}} Poor likenesses
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Steven Lejeune]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses		\| [[Steven Lejeune]] \|\| F \|\| {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */ alpha, add coments

2009-01-09T07:04:45Z

Artist grades: alpha, add coments

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:04, 9 January 2009
Line 5:		Line 5:
	\| '''Artist''' \|\| '''Grade''' \|\| '''Critique and Comments'''		\| '''Artist''' \|\| '''Grade''' \|\| '''Critique and Comments'''
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Jason Badower]] \|\| A \|\| {{plus}} Spot on likenesses <br />{{plus}} Deep, Moody, coloring <br />{{plus}} Crisp and solid <br />{{plus}} Otherworldly/cinematic quality to art <br />{{plus}} High impact action		\| [[Jason Badower]] \|\| A+ \|\| {{plus}} Spot on likenesses <br />{{plus}} Deep, Moody, coloring <br />{{plus}} Crisp and solid <br />{{plus}} Otherworldly/cinematic quality to art <br />{{plus}} High impact action
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Robert Atkins]] \|\| A \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean with rich texture <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br />{{plus}} Good likenesses <br />{{plus}} Great work in ''[[Bounty Hunter]]'' <br />{{plus}} Soft, yet solid		\| [[Robert Atkins]] \|\| A \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean with rich texture <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br />{{plus}} Good likenesses <br />{{plus}} Great work in ''[[Bounty Hunter]]'' <br />{{plus}} Soft, yet solid
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Michael Gaydos]] \|\| B+ \|\| {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well		\| [[Michael Gaydos]] \|\| A \|\| {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips		\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips
		⚫	\|-
		⚫	\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight
	\|-		\|-
	\| The [[Kotzebue]] bros. \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Good likenesses		\| The [[Kotzebue]] bros. \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Good likenesses
Line 19:		Line 21:
	\| [[Alitha Martinez]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Largely soft and smooth <br> {{plus}} Art sparkles a little <br /> {{minus}} Flat faces in profile shots at times <br /> {{minus}} Slight babyface-ness		\| [[Alitha Martinez]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Largely soft and smooth <br> {{plus}} Art sparkles a little <br /> {{minus}} Flat faces in profile shots at times <br /> {{minus}} Slight babyface-ness
	\|-		\|-
			\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}}Nice rendering of [[Anna]] in ''[[Red Eye (disambig)\|Red Eye]]''
⚫	\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight
⚫	\|-
⚫	\| [[Dan Panosian]] \|\| C \|\| {{note}}Angular art with thick lines
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Ryan Odagawa]] \|\| C+ \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean		\| [[Ryan Odagawa]] \|\| C+ \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean
⚫	\|-
⚫	\| [[Micah Gunnell]] \|\| C \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean <br /> {{plus}} Conveys energy somewhat well <br /> {{plus}} despite a [[:Image:Haitian chasing Peter.jpg\|glaring error]], good work on ''[[Our Lady of Blessed Acceleration]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses at times, making characters hard to recognize <br />{{minus}} Lack of detail in wide shots <br /> {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Adam Archer]] \|\| C \|\| none		\| [[Adam Archer]] \|\| C \|\| none
	\|-		\|-
		⚫	\| [[Micah Gunnell]] \|\| C \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean <br /> {{plus}} Conveys energy somewhat well <br /> {{plus}} despite a [[:Image:Haitian chasing Peter.jpg\|glaring error]], good work on ''[[Our Lady of Blessed Acceleration]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses at times, making characters hard to recognize <br />{{minus}} Lack of detail in wide shots <br /> {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering
	\| [[Marcus To]] \|\| C \|\| none
		⚫	\|-
		⚫	\| [[Dan Panosian]] \|\| C \|\| {{note}} Angular art with thick lines
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Peter Steigerwald]] \|\| C- \|\| {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times		\| [[Peter Steigerwald]] \|\| C- \|\| {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */ Add newest artist

2009-01-06T20:19:28Z

Artist grades: Add newest artist

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:19, 6 January 2009
Line 10:		Line 10:
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Michael Gaydos]] \|\| B+ \|\| {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well		\| [[Michael Gaydos]] \|\| B+ \|\| {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well
			\|-
			\| [[Dennis Calero]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips
	\|-		\|-
	\| The [[Kotzebue]] bros. \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Good likenesses		\| The [[Kotzebue]] bros. \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Good likenesses

imported>SacValleyDweller: /* Artist grades */ Add Dan

2008-11-20T07:27:20Z

Artist grades: Add Dan

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:27, 20 November 2008
Line 18:		Line 18:
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight		\| [[Tom Grummett]] \|\| B \|\| {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)\|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight
			\|-
			\| [[Dan Panosian]] \|\| C \|\| {{note}}Angular art with thick lines
	\|-		\|-
	\| [[Ryan Odagawa]] \|\| C+ \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean		\| [[Ryan Odagawa]] \|\| C+ \|\| {{plus}} Smooth and clean