|First appearance||Betty, Part 4|
A pig-tailed cheerleader goes to Betty's high school.
Ten minutes before the Homecoming pep rally, the black-haired jock is talking with the redhead, black-haired, brown-haired, and pig-tailed cheerleaders. The black-haired jock admits to them that he was involved in what happened to Ren Metzger, but blames Ren for his own fall down the hill and subsequent death. After the announcement for the pep rally is repeated, the pig-tailed cheerleader accompanies a different jock to the pep rally.
A high school administrator convenes the pep rally and the cheer squad, including the pig-tailed cheerleader, begins to rally. Betty creates mass illusions starting with making the pig-tailed cheerleader's skin appear to melt. The pig-tailed cheerleader screams "RRRIIOOGGLLL...!" as she witnesses what appears to be happening to herself. After the illusions fade, the students and faculty are still in shock from what happened. The pig-tailed cheerleader hugs the black-haired and redhead cheerleaders in fright and asks "Who's...Who's doing this to us?!"
- The pig-tailed cheerleader has similar hair color to the brown-haired cheerleader, but she wears her hair in pig-tails instead of straight.