Template talk:AppearancesRoot and Branch, Part 3: Difference between revisions
imported>Pierre No edit summary |
imported>Baldbobbo No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
To list the characters as they are known at the time of the release might seem like a good idea, but it totally spoils the point including # of appearances in [[List of character appearances by graphic novel]], since it makes it impossible to trace the characters ("[[Evs Dropper clone]]" is said to make his third appearance in "[[Into the Wild, Part 1]]", although he currently appears not to be mentioned prior in the list (unless you know that "Escape clone" is another fan-made reference to him. |
To list the characters as they are known at the time of the release might seem like a good idea, but it totally spoils the point including # of appearances in [[List of character appearances by graphic novel]], since it makes it impossible to trace the characters ("[[Evs Dropper clone]]" is said to make his third appearance in "[[Into the Wild, Part 1]]", although he currently appears not to be mentioned prior in the list (unless you know that "Escape clone" is another fan-made reference to him. |
||
The comparison with Mr Bennet isn't valid, since "Mr. Bennet" was what he officially was referred to prior to ep#1x23. "Evs Dropper clone" and "Escape clone" are both fanmade terms, and to list him as both only is confusing. [[User:Pierre|Pierre]] 15:46, 8 September 2008 (EDT) |
The comparison with Mr Bennet isn't valid, since "Mr. Bennet" was what he officially was referred to prior to ep#1x23. "Evs Dropper clone" and "Escape clone" are both fanmade terms, and to list him as both only is confusing. [[User:Pierre|Pierre]] 15:46, 8 September 2008 (EDT) |
||
* A better comparison would be with "Austin" and "Dallas" or Kensei. It's what we have done, and it does make sense if you are following the plots.--{{User:Baldbobbo/sig}} 14:18, 12 September 2008 (EDT) |
|||
Revision as of 18:18, 12 September 2008
To list the characters as they are known at the time of the release might seem like a good idea, but it totally spoils the point including # of appearances in List of character appearances by graphic novel, since it makes it impossible to trace the characters ("Evs Dropper clone" is said to make his third appearance in "Into the Wild, Part 1", although he currently appears not to be mentioned prior in the list (unless you know that "Escape clone" is another fan-made reference to him. The comparison with Mr Bennet isn't valid, since "Mr. Bennet" was what he officially was referred to prior to ep#1x23. "Evs Dropper clone" and "Escape clone" are both fanmade terms, and to list him as both only is confusing. Pierre 15:46, 8 September 2008 (EDT)