Theory:Charlie Andrews

Main Article Theories about Charlie Andrews Main Discussion

The following fan theories are about Charlie Andrews.

For help on adding theories, see the help section.

Theories

Theory	Citations	Notes
Charlie is merely a victim of time. No matter how much Hiro bends time and space, Charlie dies at the same time.	Hiro tells Ando he couldn't save her, no matter how hard he tried.(Six Months Ago)	• Because of his failure to save Charlie, Hiro believes he cannot change the past.
The Haitian visited Charlie and erased some of her memories.	None.	+ In Seven Minutes to Midnight, she says that she had started only a week before reading the Japanese phrase book she received for her birthday six months earlier. In Six Months Ago, she started using the book right away. Altering her memory may have interfered with Hiro's efforts to save her — even though he bought her a ticket to Japan, her memory of being told to leave was erased. - Short of Hiro meeting The Haitian in the future, winning his trust and being given a way to prove himself to The Haitian in the past so that he could convince him to go and erase Charlie's memory, there's no way this scenario could work. - It is possible that Hiro simply remembered Charlie enjoying learning Japanese and went ahead and bought her a Japanese book himself.
Charlie knew of her impending death, and of Hiro in the changed time line. She simply did not acknowledge that she already knew Hiro. She accepted her death at the hands of Sylar because she was going to die of the blood clot anyway.	Ando doesn't remember anything differently. (Six Months Ago)	- This doesn't account for the changing photo, however. (1,2)
Hiro's actions did create some changes in the past, but he is apparently unable to make a change that would create a causality paradox: he cannot change the past in such a way that it would prevent him from going into the past.	The different versions of Charlie's birthday photo (and Ando's reaction to the change) indicate the past has changed. (Six Months Ago)	- Due to the events in How to Stop an Exploding Man, the explosion didn't occur within New York City, which was the catalyst for Future Hiro going back to warn Peter Petrelli in the first place. :+ It may be that in the changed timeline Hiro eventually decides to go back in time and give Peter the message anyway, to prevent the paradox.
Hiro's time traveling did change the "present," as evidenced by the changed picture.	None.	+ Hiro does not know what happened in the changed timeline; Charlie could well have known who he was. • This does not account for Ando remembering the "original" timeline. See his theory page.