Episode talk:Thanksgiving: Difference between revisions
imported>NileQT87 |
imported>NileQT87 |
||
| Line 151: | Line 151: | ||
* Although you're correct that this takes place on Thanksgiving, and almost definitely correct that it is meant to take place in 2009, if we place this entire season in 2009, it would automatically negate other canon sources. Since the timeline is off and canon sources contradict each other, we won't be able to place any events for Volume Five. See [[Talk:Timeline:Post-March 2007#200when?|here]]. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 00:16, 24 November 2009 (EST) |
* Although you're correct that this takes place on Thanksgiving, and almost definitely correct that it is meant to take place in 2009, if we place this entire season in 2009, it would automatically negate other canon sources. Since the timeline is off and canon sources contradict each other, we won't be able to place any events for Volume Five. See [[Talk:Timeline:Post-March 2007#200when?|here]]. -- {{User:Ryangibsonstewart/sig}} 00:16, 24 November 2009 (EST) |
||
** While I agree the timeline's a mess, since the start of Volume Five, all signs point to 2009 as far as I've seen. At the very least, The Caged Bird (a Vol.3 GN) takes place in October 2007, so this would have to at least be 2008. During Thanksgiving break, I'm going to be looking through the old episodes and see what I can to do reconstruct some kind of timeline out of it (already starting with the comics on [[User:Ricard_Desi/Condensed_timeline]]). But stuff that is related to this episode (some of the surrounding episodes, [[Slow Burn, Part 9]], and details surrounding Suresh's, Joseph's, and Danko's deaths) would fall in late Autumn 2009. --[[User:Ricard Desi|Ricard Desi]] ([[User talk:Ricard Desi|t]],[[Special:Contributions/Ricard Desi|c]]) |
** While I agree the timeline's a mess, since the start of Volume Five, all signs point to 2009 as far as I've seen. At the very least, The Caged Bird (a Vol.3 GN) takes place in October 2007, so this would have to at least be 2008. During Thanksgiving break, I'm going to be looking through the old episodes and see what I can to do reconstruct some kind of timeline out of it (already starting with the comics on [[User:Ricard_Desi/Condensed_timeline]]). But stuff that is related to this episode (some of the surrounding episodes, [[Slow Burn, Part 9]], and details surrounding Suresh's, Joseph's, and Danko's deaths) would fall in late Autumn 2009. --[[User:Ricard Desi|Ricard Desi]] ([[User talk:Ricard Desi|t]],[[Special:Contributions/Ricard Desi|c]]) |
||
*** The most maneuverable split is between volumes 3 and 4. The only in-series time that a date was stated between there was Tracy saying that she hadn't seen Nathan in 2 months. That's not necessarily the night of the Pinehearst fire. It's the only thing that works. In fact, even if this season is taking place in 2007, there is more than a 2-month split between volumes 3 and 4 anyway. [[User:NileQT87|NileQT87]] 00:45, 24 November 2009 (EST) |
*** The most maneuverable split is between volumes 3 and 4. The only in-series time that a date was stated between there was Tracy saying that she hadn't seen Nathan in 2 months. That's not necessarily the night of the Pinehearst fire. It's the only thing that works. In fact, even if this season is taking place in 2007, there is more than a 2-month split between volumes 3 and 4 anyway. Also, please somebody do something about the dumb thing where October 1st is the date of the eclipse. You realize that means that Claire and Zach went to school on a Sunday, right? Not to mention the fact that Sylar's watch tells the day of the month (September 24 + 4 days = September 28, the day of the eclipse--and not a school day!). And not every episode takes place only on one day. That whole timeline is a nightmare. [[User:NileQT87|NileQT87]] 00:45, 24 November 2009 (EST) |
||
Revision as of 05:47, 24 November 2009
|
New episode checklist
| see also current graphic novel and current graphic novel checklist | jump to table of contents |
Episode UpdatesEpisode article: Update/add other articles: Update Main Page: ___ Update songs |
Character UpdatesUpdate Main Character pages Update character-related pages |
Character/Reference/Powers UpdatesUpdate other character pages as needed Add new character pages as needed: Add new actor pages as needed: "Despoil" new characters and actors who already have articles: Add references to appropriate recurring themes: Add examples of Powers used: |
Miscellaneous UpdatesEvents/Items/Things/etc. World Locations Places Timeline Update templates as needed |
New ImagesGet screencaps: New characters (200x250): New groups (450x350) New Events/Items/Things/etc. (450x350) New locations (450x350) New places (450x350) All powers used (450x350) |
Mohinder and Rene
They were credited as appearing, but where were they?--Ratclaws 22:07, 23 November 2009 (EST)
- Mohinder was 8 wks in the future and Rene wasn't there... ~~IHH—Talk 22:11, 23 November 2009 (EST)
- Mohinder was 8 weeks in the past. Just saying... --King Zach 03:37, 24 November 2009
- In the original version of the episode (circa two or three months ago) Rene was supposed to be in the episode...but I can't say much more than that. I don't know if there was a scene that was filmed and cut, if there was a scene that was written and cut, or if there was a scene that was moved to another episode. -- RyanGibsonStewart (talk) 23:15, 23 November 2009 (EST)
- Mohinder was 8 weeks in the past. Just saying... --King Zach 03:37, 24 November 2009
Redemption Timeline
Well, we already had a pretty good idea that this season takes place in 2009, and this episode took place on Thanksgiving, so this episode would be November 26, 2009. Time to start placing Volume Five events... --Ricard Desi (t,c) 23:54, 23 November 2009 (EST)
- Although you're correct that this takes place on Thanksgiving, and almost definitely correct that it is meant to take place in 2009, if we place this entire season in 2009, it would automatically negate other canon sources. Since the timeline is off and canon sources contradict each other, we won't be able to place any events for Volume Five. See here. -- RyanGibsonStewart (talk) 00:16, 24 November 2009 (EST)
- While I agree the timeline's a mess, since the start of Volume Five, all signs point to 2009 as far as I've seen. At the very least, The Caged Bird (a Vol.3 GN) takes place in October 2007, so this would have to at least be 2008. During Thanksgiving break, I'm going to be looking through the old episodes and see what I can to do reconstruct some kind of timeline out of it (already starting with the comics on User:Ricard_Desi/Condensed_timeline). But stuff that is related to this episode (some of the surrounding episodes, Slow Burn, Part 9, and details surrounding Suresh's, Joseph's, and Danko's deaths) would fall in late Autumn 2009. --Ricard Desi (t,c)
- The most maneuverable split is between volumes 3 and 4. The only in-series time that a date was stated between there was Tracy saying that she hadn't seen Nathan in 2 months. That's not necessarily the night of the Pinehearst fire. It's the only thing that works. In fact, even if this season is taking place in 2007, there is more than a 2-month split between volumes 3 and 4 anyway. Also, please somebody do something about the dumb thing where October 1st is the date of the eclipse. You realize that means that Claire and Zach went to school on a Sunday, right? Not to mention the fact that Sylar's watch tells the day of the month (September 24 + 4 days = September 28, the day of the eclipse--and not a school day!). And not every episode takes place only on one day. That whole timeline is a nightmare. NileQT87 00:45, 24 November 2009 (EST)
- While I agree the timeline's a mess, since the start of Volume Five, all signs point to 2009 as far as I've seen. At the very least, The Caged Bird (a Vol.3 GN) takes place in October 2007, so this would have to at least be 2008. During Thanksgiving break, I'm going to be looking through the old episodes and see what I can to do reconstruct some kind of timeline out of it (already starting with the comics on User:Ricard_Desi/Condensed_timeline). But stuff that is related to this episode (some of the surrounding episodes, Slow Burn, Part 9, and details surrounding Suresh's, Joseph's, and Danko's deaths) would fall in late Autumn 2009. --Ricard Desi (t,c)