Theory:Compass

Main Article Theories about the compass Main Discussion

The following fan theories are about the compass.

For help on adding theories, see the help section.

Theories

Theory	Citations	Notes
Sylar will fix the compass.	None.	+ He has the ability which helps him in repairing broken things. • The compass might not actually be broken, maybe it only responds to evolved humans. + Sylar appeared in Lydia's tattoo, proving at least that Samuel will be looking for him.
The compass points at people with abilities.	None.	+ A real compass has the same behavior at the magnetic north/south poles as when Peter held it. + What else would Danko have thought "was worth dying for"? - If this were the case, why wouldn't it point toward Peter when Noah held it? It didn't seem to move at all until Peter was holding it. + Maybe it only points to people with abilities when held by someone with abilities. - In that case, it would only point to the hero holding it, making it worthless. + Maybe it's supposed to bring people with abilities together, pointing other evolved humans. + Danko was able to find Mohinder in Coyote Sands in 1961, how did he do that without something to help him with that? - He could have tracked him on his way there, same he did with Sylar and Luke, and since he was working for the government, it's possible he had access to files on what happened in Coyote Sands. + There is a big chance that the company did delete all those files. - Company also gave what was left of their own files to the government.
The compass points at a treasure.	Maybe not at chests with gold or anything, but at other mysterious objects like the fortune teller's crystal.	+ The compass doesn't seem to point at north, and it works only in hands of evolved humans. Perhaps it points at something significant. - The compass didn't point in a specific direction with Peter, it just spinned wildly.
The compass points to something in the carnival.	None.	+ Samuel says that all evolved humans will come to the family. - They also need Bennet at the carnival since he appeared on a tattoo on Lydia's back.
The compass is used to detect people with abilites.	None.	+ It reacted when Peter used it, but not when Noah had it. + It spinned when Samuel held it. + This would make it very valuable to a family of evolved humans, as it allows them to see who has abilities.
The compass is related with Claire's wind chime somehow.	None.	+ Both are obviously related with evolved humans. One calls an evolved human and other only works with evolved humans.
The compass is insignificant. Samuel just wants to throw it back into Joseph's grave.	None.	+ Samuel was angry at Danko and sent Edgar to kill him because Danko "crossed the line" (Running in Circles).
Certain compasses work for certain people.	None.	+ In Orientation, just before Samuel through Joseph's compass in his grave, it did not move. + However Samuel's compass worked for him. So maybe only Joseph's compass worked for him. And maybe the compass in Danko's bank account works for only Peter (a reason why Samuel wanted him). • The compass Samuel threw in Joseph's grave and the one Edgar retrieved are the same compass. • No, they are two separate compasses. • Samuel sends Edgar to kill Danko, saying, "Get the compass back and kill the son of a bitch... It's what Joseph would've wanted". This implies Danko stole the compass from Joseph's grave.
The compass points at the carnival	None	+ When Tracy considers Samuel's offer, the compass stops spinning wildly and points in a direction.
Someone at the Carnival has the ability to imbue objects with supernatural abilities.	None	+ This would explain the compass' erratic behavior and significance.