This wiki is a XML full dump clone of "Heroes Wiki", the main wiki about the Heroes saga that has been shut down permanently since June 1, 2020. The purpose of this wiki is to keep online an exhaustive and accurate database about the franchise.

User:SacValleyDweller/Artist grades: Difference between revisions

From Heroes Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Content deleted Content added
imported>SacValleyDweller
make this to make editing a section of my page easier to manage
 
imported>SacValleyDweller
m alpha
 
(10 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
| '''Artist''' || '''Grade''' || '''Critique and Comments'''
| '''Artist''' || '''Grade''' || '''Critique and Comments'''
|-
|-
| [[Jason Badower]] || A || {{plus}} Spot on likenesses <br />{{plus}} Deep, Moody, coloring <br />{{plus}} Crisp and solid <br />{{plus}} Otherworldly/cinematic quality to art <br />{{plus}} High impact action
| [[Jason Badower]] || A+ || {{plus}} Spot on likenesses <br />{{plus}} Deep, Moody, coloring <br />{{plus}} Crisp and solid <br />{{plus}} Otherworldly/cinematic quality to art <br />{{plus}} High impact action
|-
|-
| [[Robert Atkins]] || A || {{plus}} Smooth and clean with rich texture <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br />{{plus}} Good likenesses <br />{{plus}} Great work in ''[[Bounty Hunter]]'' <br />{{plus}} Soft, yet solid
| [[Robert Atkins]] || A || {{plus}} Smooth and clean with rich texture <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br />{{plus}} Good likenesses <br />{{plus}} Great work in ''[[Bounty Hunter]]'' <br />{{plus}} Soft, yet solid
|-
|-
| [[Michael Gaydos]] || B+ || {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well
| [[Michael Gaydos]] || A || {{plus}} Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture<br /> {{plus}} Good likenesses <br /> {{plus}} Conveys shadow and darkness well <br /> {{plus}} Conveys action moderately well
|-
| [[Dennis Calero]] || B + || {{plus}} Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows. <br />{{minus}} Hardly any lips
|-
| [[Tom Grummett]] || B || {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight
|-
|-
| The [[Kotzebue]] bros. || B || {{plus}} Good likenesses
| The [[Kotzebue]] bros. || B || {{plus}} Good likenesses
Line 15: Line 19:
| [[Staz Johnson]] || B || {{plus}} Smooth, flowing lines <br />{{plus}} Energetic art
| [[Staz Johnson]] || B || {{plus}} Smooth, flowing lines <br />{{plus}} Energetic art
|-
|-
| [[Tom Grummett]] || B-/C+ || {{plus}} Gritty lines <br /> {{plus}} Flowing lines convey energy and action well <br /> {{plus}} Good work on ''[[Revolutionary War (disambig)|Revolutionary War]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses due to lumpiness <br /> {{minus}} Clothes drawn fitting too tight
| [[Alitha Martinez]] || B || {{plus}} Largely soft and smooth <br> {{plus}} Art sparkles a little <br /> {{minus}} Flat faces in profile shots at times <br /> {{minus}} Slight babyface-ness
|-
| [[Siya Oum]] || B || {{note}} Art is like oil paintings
|-
⚫
| [[Luis Puig]] || B || none
|-
| [[Marcus To]] || B || {{plus}} Cartoony, but great guys in suits!<br />{{plus}} [[Angie]], and [[Anna]], and [[Sheila]] nicely drawn in their respective GNs
|-
| [[Phil Jimenez]] || C+ || none
|-
|-
| [[Ryan Odagawa]] || C+ || {{plus}} Smooth and clean
| [[Ryan Odagawa]] || C+ || {{plus}} Smooth and clean
Line 21: Line 33:
| [[Adam Archer]] || C || none
| [[Adam Archer]] || C || none
|-
|-
⚫
| [[Micah Gunnell]] || C || {{plus}} Smooth and clean <br /> {{plus}} Conveys energy somewhat well <br /> {{plus}} despite a [[:Image:Haitian chasing Peter.jpg|glaring error]], good work on ''[[Our Lady of Blessed Acceleration]]'' <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses at times, making characters hard to recognize <br />{{minus}} Lack of detail in wide shots <br /> {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering
⚫
| [[Marcus To]] || C || none
|-
| [[Dan Panosian]] || C || {{note}} Angular art with thick lines
|-
|-
| [[Peter Steigerwald]] || C- || {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines
| [[Peter Steigerwald]] || C- || {{minus}} Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times
|-
|-
| [[ChrisCross]] || D || {{minus}} Poor likenesses
⚫
| [[Micah Gunnell]] || D+ || {{plus}} Smooth and clean <br /> {{plus}} Conveys energy somewhat well <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses at times, making characters hard to recognize <br />{{minus}} Lack of detail in wide shots <br /> {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering
|-
|-
| [[Alitha Martinez]] || D || {{note}} Art is smooth and clean sometimes, but rough at other times <br /> {{minus}} Flat faces in profile shots at times <br /> {{minus}} [[Penny]] drawn too ugly in ''[[Faces, Part 1]]''
| [[Greg Beeman]] || F || {{minus}} Poor likenesses <br /> {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering
|-
|-
| [[Steven Lejeune]] || F || {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses
| [[Steven Lejeune]] || F || {{minus}} Poor anatomical rendering <br /> {{minus}} Poor likenesses

Latest revision as of 05:48, 22 December 2009

Artist grades

With regards to the artists themselves, I give them the following grades and my critiques and comments on them. Not surprisingly, my favoritism of the GNs themselves on the basis of art alone tends to follow these grades

Artist Grade Critique and Comments
Jason Badower A+ + Spot on likenesses
+ Deep, Moody, coloring
+ Crisp and solid
+ Otherworldly/cinematic quality to art
+ High impact action
Robert Atkins A + Smooth and clean with rich texture
+ Flowing lines convey energy and action well
+ Good likenesses
+ Great work in Bounty Hunter
+ Soft, yet solid
Michael Gaydos A + Gritty, thick, rough, earthy texture
+ Good likenesses
+ Conveys shadow and darkness well
+ Conveys action moderately well
Dennis Calero B + + Somewhat rough, with good use of shadows.
- Hardly any lips
Tom Grummett B + Gritty lines
+ Flowing lines convey energy and action well
+ Good work on Revolutionary War
- Too lumpy, especially with regards to the cheek bones & chins
- Poor likenesses due to lumpiness
- Clothes drawn fitting too tight
The Kotzebue bros. B + Good likenesses
Staz Johnson B + Smooth, flowing lines
+ Energetic art
Alitha Martinez B + Largely soft and smooth
+ Art sparkles a little
- Flat faces in profile shots at times
- Slight babyface-ness
Siya Oum B • Art is like oil paintings
Luis Puig B none
Marcus To B + Cartoony, but great guys in suits!
+ Angie, and Anna, and Sheila nicely drawn in their respective GNs
Phil Jimenez C+ none
Ryan Odagawa C+ + Smooth and clean
Adam Archer C none
Micah Gunnell C + Smooth and clean
+ Conveys energy somewhat well
+ despite a glaring error, good work on Our Lady of Blessed Acceleration
- Poor likenesses at times, making characters hard to recognize
- Lack of detail in wide shots
- Poor anatomical rendering
Dan Panosian C • Angular art with thick lines
Peter Steigerwald C- - Too rough for the thinness of the lines at times
ChrisCross D - Poor likenesses
Greg Beeman F - Poor likenesses
- Poor anatomical rendering
Steven Lejeune F - Poor anatomical rendering
- Poor likenesses
Eric Nguyen F - Dirty, sketchy, thin lines


Usage

Puts my artist grades in my userpage ion the appropriate section in order to keep said section less congested in the editing box

Retrieved from "https://heroeswiki.ddns.net/index.php?title=User:SacValleyDweller/Artist_grades&oldid=178146"