Theory:Hiro Nakamura: Difference between revisions
imported>Josh removed spoiler |
imported>Josh update, cleanup |
||
| Line 60: | Line 60: | ||
{{minus}} Hiro's mother is Ishi.<br /> |
{{minus}} Hiro's mother is Ishi.<br /> |
||
:{{plus}} She may not be his biological mother.<br /> |
:{{plus}} She may not be his biological mother.<br /> |
||
|- |
|||
| [[Hiro]] did not lose his power, despite what [[Arthur]] may have said. || None. || {{plus}} [[Hiro]] did not seem to experience pain like [[Maya]] and [[Peter]] did.<br /> |
|||
:{{plus}} It is possible that Arthur wants Hiro to believe he can't [[Space-time manipulation|manipulate time]] so Hiro won't try to return to the present.<br /> |
|||
::{{plus}} Hiro has 'lost' his ability in the past by not believing he could use it.<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} Maybe Hiro has a higher threshold for pain.<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} Maybe there's something inherent to his ability that did not cause pain when it was lost.<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} He was also immediately thrown through the air by Arthur and we did not see him for a few minutes. Perhaps when off-screen is when he exhibited the pain that he was in.<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} Maya did not seem to exhibit pain when Arthur took her power. It seemed like she was more uncomfortable.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} Arthur was a villain and tried to kill Hiro.<br /> |
|||
|- |
|||
| If [[Hiro]] did in fact lose his ability, he will gain a new [[ability]], later in the show, when he is injected by a new [[formula]]. || None. || {{plus}} The same thing happened to [[Peter]].<br /> |
|||
:{{plus}} From a writer's standpoint, [[Peter]] and [[Hiro]] were both too powerful. Having them both lose their abilities and gain new ones that are similar but different would be a good idea.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} [[Mohinder]] has stated that the type of abilities a person has/receives are dependent upon the person's DNA make-up. So [[Hiro]] should receive the ''same'' ability he had prior to [[Arthur]] taking it...[[space-time manipulation]].<br /> |
|||
:{{plus}} He may get a reduced form of his original power. E.g. teleportation or slowing time down, but just not time travel.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} The [[serum]] made with the formula has been destroyed, and so has the [[Catalyst]].<br /> |
|||
:{{plus}} The theory states that Hiro will gain a new ability from a ''new'' formula that may or may not require a catalyst.<br /> |
|||
:{{plus}} Some vials of serum still exist, as evidenced by the ''[[The Recruit]]'' webisodes.<br /> |
|||
::{{minus}} Those vials were uncatalyzed, not viable for use.<br /> |
|||
|- |
|- |
||
| All of [[Hiro]]'s time travel ventures were predestination [[paradox]]es. || [[Hiro]] and [[Claire]] were already in [[Isaac]]'s comic book. (''[[Our Father]]'') || {{plus}} [[Hiro]] became [[Takezo Kensei]] when he traveled to 1671.<br /> |
| All of [[Hiro]]'s time travel ventures were predestination [[paradox]]es. || [[Hiro]] and [[Claire]] were already in [[Isaac]]'s comic book. (''[[Our Father]]'') || {{plus}} [[Hiro]] became [[Takezo Kensei]] when he traveled to 1671.<br /> |
||
{{note}} Not all of his time traveling instances would be predestination paradoxes; only the trips to the past would be. But this was probably implied in the theory.<br /> |
{{note}} Not all of his time traveling instances would be predestination paradoxes; only the trips to the past would be. But this was probably implied in the theory.<br /> |
||
|- |
|||
| [[Hiro]]'s ability will be restored by [[Ando]]. || None. || {{plus}} Ando's ability can supercharge those who already have abilities.<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} This in no way suggests that Ando will be able to give abilities.<br /> |
|||
:{{plus}} When he uses his ability against [[Hiro]] in the ''[[The Second Coming]]'', it is presumed that he would have the same ability as he does in the present, which is power enhancement, not an offensive ability.<br /> |
|||
::{{plus}} Indeed, when Peter injected himself with a formula, he was shocked, though he didn't pass out. If Ando was restoring Hiro's ability, it's likely the latter fell unconscious.<br /> |
|||
::{{note}} When [[Ando]] injected himself with [[the formula]] he passed out.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} Maybe Hiro still had powers in the exposed future, and supercharging space-time manipulation could be lethal.<br /> |
|||
|- |
|- |
||
| Hiro will gain precognitive dreams. || None. || {{plus}} Matt also experienced spirit walks, and now can see the future.<br /> |
| Hiro will gain precognitive dreams. || None. || {{plus}} Matt also experienced spirit walks, and now can see the future.<br /> |
||
{{minus}} Hiro hasn't seen Usutu in visions, Matt only started seeing the future after talking with a vision of Usutu.<br /> |
{{minus}} Hiro hasn't seen Usutu in visions, Matt only started seeing the future after talking with a vision of Usutu.<br /> |
||
|- |
|||
| [[Hiro]] still has a power. May not be [[space-time manipulation]]. || He was taken, and put onto the plane in ''[[A Clear and Present Danger]]''. || {{minus}} As far as the government knows, Hiro still has his ability, they don't know Arthur took it.<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} Mohinder's suggestion that the government might let Hiro go if he turns himself in and explain his situation supports this.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} The writers have stated that they are phasing out time travel, this is why all time-travelers are now dead or without that ability:<br /> |
|||
:{{note}} Arthur is dead.<br /> |
|||
:{{note}} Peter has lost his original ability and has no time travelers to absorb from.<br /> |
|||
{{plus}} Hiro was a likable character, for him to be powerless and lose his "hero's quest" would be disappointing for some viewers.<br /> |
|||
:{{note}} Hiro ''was'' a likable character, some viewers are not happy with the direction the character has taken.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} When Arthur took the catalyst he also mentioned he'd be taking Hiro's powers too.<br /> |
|||
{{plus}} Who's to say Arthur didn't take Hiro's powers, just erased his memory of being able to control the powers?<br /> |
|||
:{{minus}} The writers have been explicit on removing time-travel as a plot device.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} Arthur removed Hiro's ability, and the formula is no more. There are no known ways to return Hiro abilities.<br /> |
|||
|- |
|- |
||
| Hiro will die in Volume 4. || None. || {{ |
| Hiro will die in Volume 4. || None. || {{minus}} Hiro has been a main character since [[Genesis]], to kill him would cause some anger amongst viewers.<br /> |
||
{{note}} This would be interesting, by removing time travel they are causing the death of a main character.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} Hiro has been a main character since [[Genesis]], to kill him would cause some anger amongst viewers.<br /> |
|||
{{plus}} Hiro has been killed in every possible future we have seen.<br /> |
{{plus}} Hiro has been killed in every possible future we have seen.<br /> |
||
{{plus}} Hiro's death could cause an uprising of evolved humans against Nathan's regime.<br /> |
{{plus}} Hiro's death could cause an uprising of evolved humans against Nathan's regime.<br /> |
||
{{minus}} Ando didn't had powers in Volume One, but he wasn't killed, though he even attempted to kill Sylar alone. Why should a powerless Hiro die now? Besides, Hiro and Ando always were a good team, Hiro just needs to get used they've switched the roles.<br /> |
|||
{{note}} Ando wasn't as annoying and as whiny as Hiro is being now.<br /> |
|||
{{note}} Another difference is that we have experienced Hiro with an ability and liked it, now he has lost it is just disappointing, akin to Peter's current ability.<br /> |
|||
{{minus}} The writers promised Hiro would eventually regain his ability.<br /> |
|||
|- |
|- |
||
| If [[Ando]] were to [[ability supercharging| |
| If [[Ando]] were to [[ability supercharging|supercharge]] Hiro, Hiro would once again be able to use the full extent of [[space-time manipulation]]. |
||
|| None. || |
|| None. || |
||
{{plus}} Hiro's current ability seems to be identical to his previous one, but weaker. He may just need more energy to work with. <br /> |
{{plus}} Hiro's current ability seems to be identical to his previous one, but weaker. He may just need more energy to work with. <br /> |
||
Revision as of 19:26, 26 March 2009
|
The following fan theories are about Hiro Nakamura.
For help on adding theories, see the help section.
Theories
| Theory | Citations | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Hiro's powers resulted from mutations in his grandfather's DNA. These mutations were caused by the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima. | Hiro's grandfather was a survivor of Hiroshima and died of cancer. (The Crane) | - In an interview, George Takei strongly implied that Takezo Kensei is Hiro's ancestor. He says that through that legendary samurai, he is bringing a lot of good DNA to this role. This means that Hiro's DNA mutations were obtained from Kensei, not the atomic bomb.
- There have never been any documented cases that mutations from exposure to nuclear energy have been passed on to offspring.
- This is generally baseless, or at the very least a stretch. |
| Hiro's powers have not fully developed. When they do he will be able to summon anything from anywhere to any point in time. | None. | + Many of the powers take practice and time to develop. • Future Hiro did not display such an ability. Had he possessed it, he could have brought Future Peter to him and Ando, rather than traveling to Las Vegas, or simply summoned present-day Hiro from the Homeland Security building. He may have not fully developed his powers in the period of five years, however.
+ Future Peter, who is considerably more experienced with space-time manipulation, was able to teleport Matt to Africa seemingly without actually going there himself.
- Hiro no longer has an ability. |
| Hiro did not actually change history when he time-traveled to ancient Japan; events as they are unfolding now are exactly the events that occurred in the first place. | None. | • This is a predestination paradox. + In the stories that Hiro was told by his father, Kensei was Japanese, (like Hiro) not a gaijin. It seems he was destined to return to feudal Japan and become the hero.
+ The "Battle of Twelve Swords" fits more into the context of Hiro's time-stop ability than Kensei's regeneration; if Kensei had gone into the battle, it is unlikely he would have simply disarmed the opponents.
+ This could explain why the depictions of Kensei in the Sword Saint documentaries looks less like Kensei, and more like Hiro.
+ If a time traveling man in the future goes back to the past, then the present man would already see the changes his future self made in the past, considering they took place in the past. Basically Hiro, before he went to the past, would have to be living in a world in which his future self already ‘altered’ the past, because it took place in the past and would have already happened. So throughout Hiro’s entire life the events that took place with Hiro in the past, had already taken place, and all the effects of that would have already been weaved throughout the current timeline before Hiro even decided to go to the past.
|
| Every time Hiro time travels, he causes a catastrophe such as the bomb that explodes in New York and the plague that Peter and Caitlin saw. | None. | + In the graphic novel String Theory, it shows he went back in time to stop Sylar from getting Claire's power so he could be killed. Doing so may have made Peter the exploding man instead of Sylar.
+ Hiro teleporting forward in time prevented him from stabbing Sylar in the explosion future.
+ Hiro traveled back in time, retrieved the catalyst from his mother, Ishi, and then allowed the catalyst to fall into Arthur's hands, thus eventually completing the formula. |
| Hiro could travel between alternate universes/timelines. | None. | + Hiro has gone to futures that did not happen. They could be futures of alternate universes. - It is possible that the future that he visited was a product of him being "out of the equation" as he was able to prevent Claire from being killed, but didn't stab Sylar (as he wasn't there in that timeline).
+ It is possible he could develop this power. Matt has discovered more facets of his ability he didn't realise before; so could Hiro. |
| Hiro Nakamura is brothers with Nathan and Peter Petrelli. | Hiro's biological mother may actually be Angela Petrelli, since we know she slept with Kaito Nakamura. | - Hiro seems younger than Nathan. Giving birth to an Asian baby would probably have wrecked her marriage. Nathan would remember his mom being pregnant with a second baby. • These three characters seem to interact and affect the future far more than any other character in the entire series.
- Hiro's mother is Ishi.
|
| All of Hiro's time travel ventures were predestination paradoxes. | Hiro and Claire were already in Isaac's comic book. (Our Father) | + Hiro became Takezo Kensei when he traveled to 1671. • Not all of his time traveling instances would be predestination paradoxes; only the trips to the past would be. But this was probably implied in the theory. |
| Hiro will gain precognitive dreams. | None. | + Matt also experienced spirit walks, and now can see the future. - Hiro hasn't seen Usutu in visions, Matt only started seeing the future after talking with a vision of Usutu. |
| Hiro will die in Volume 4. | None. | - Hiro has been a main character since Genesis, to kill him would cause some anger amongst viewers. + Hiro has been killed in every possible future we have seen. |
| If Ando were to supercharge Hiro, Hiro would once again be able to use the full extent of space-time manipulation. | None. |
+ Hiro's current ability seems to be identical to his previous one, but weaker. He may just need more energy to work with. |
| |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| See Also: 9 • Red • Time travel • Hiro Nakamura | |||||||||