Theory:Charlie Andrews

Main Article Theories about Charlie Andrews Main Discussion

The following fan theories are about Charlie Andrews.

For help on adding theories, see the help section.

Theories

Theory	Citations	Notes
The Haitian visited Charlie and erased some of her memories.	None.	+ In Seven Minutes to Midnight, she says that she had started only a week before reading the Japanese phrase book she received for her birthday six months earlier. In Six Months Ago, she started using the book right away. Altering her memory may have interfered with Hiro's efforts to save her — even though he bought her a ticket to Japan, her memory of being told to leave was erased. + Someone (not necessarily The Haitian, others have been seen to manipulate memories, notably Matt Parkman) must have changed her memories or somehow compelled or convinced her not to tell Hiro of their prior meeting. Hiro must have actually traveled to the past of the "original" timeline, as Ando, who had not traveled back in time saw the picture on the board, showing that past actually did happen. Supporting that, Hiro's trips to the past have always demonstrated that his actions were predestined and affected the "main" timeline (the picture in the Diner, and Adam remembers him). So either her memories were rewritten without Hiro in them, or she was intentionally hiding them from Hiro when he first entered the Diner on his personal timeline. - Short of Hiro meeting The Haitian in the future, winning his trust and being given a way to prove himself to The Haitian in the past so that he could convince him to go and erase Charlie's memory, there's no way this scenario could work. - It is possible that Hiro simply remembered Charlie enjoying learning Japanese and went ahead and bought her a Japanese book himself. - It seems more likely this was a writers discrepancy. It's common when dealing with time travel. - If somebody from the Company visited Charlie, they would bag and tag her, and she would end just like Matt Neuenberg. • Why would someone erase Charlie's memories, especially those related to Hiro? - The events of Once Upon a Time in Texas imply that Charlie simply never met Hiro before he time traveled the first time to save her.
Charlie knew of her impending death in the changed time line. She simply did not acknowledge that she already knew Hiro when they "met for the first time". She accepted her death at the hands of Sylar because she was going to die of the blood clot anyway, and Hiro allowed her to experience love before she died.	Ando doesn't remember anything differently. (Six Months Ago)	+ The events of the novel "Saving Charlie" pretty much confirm this theory. Hiro told Charlie about her impending death and the two spent Charlie's last night alive making love before Charlie went in to work, with Hiro waiting until after his past self left to save Charlie in order to "return". - Charlie never knew Sylar would come after her. + Hiro may have warned her (or she may have puzzled out for herself) that any recognizance of Hiro could cause a paradox and wreak unknowable havoc.
Hiro's time traveling did change the "present", as evidenced by the changed picture from Charlie's birthday.	The events of the novel "Saving Charlie" pretty much confirm this theory. Hiro told Charlie about her impending death and the two spent Charlie's last night alive making love before Charlie went in to work.	+ Hiro does not know what happened in the changed timeline; Charlie could well have known who he was. In fact "Saving Charlie" suggests that Charlie feigned ignorance. - Past Hiro only appeared on Charlie's photo after future Hiro told him to go to the past.
Charlie will end like Caitlin: trapped in an inaccessible point in time, forgotten by everyone and written out of the show for good.	None	+ Samuel had Arnold trap her somewhere in time. If she is in the future, it can be averted, and Charlie may wink out of existence like Caitlin. - Samuel could have trapped her in the past, or else somewhere in a time Hiro won't need time travel to reach, like a near future. He could have made it so all Hiro needs is teleportation. + Samuel wants to manipulate Hiro, he'd make sure he left no loose ends. • It may be possible for Hiro to reach otherwise impossible timelines by way of overexerting his power. • Overexerting his power will kill Hiro. - Samuel is using Charlie to gain Hiro's loyalty. Should Hiro learn that he cannot get her back, he would instantly turn against Samuel and refuse to help him. It's possible Samuel intends to reunite them once his problems are resolved. He's not inherently evil, after all. + Arnold said, "No one deserves a fate like that..." (Bloodlines, Part 2), implying that he hid Charlie someplace dangerous. • He could betray Samuel and take Charlie to a safe place of his own choice.
Charlie is not trapped somewhere in time, but hidden somewhere in the carnival.	Charlie's name tag had fallen off in the present. (Once Upon a Time in Texas)	+ It seems unlikely that Arnold had the energy to kidnap Charlie, return to the present, travel somewhere else in time to trap her, then return to the present to die. - Samuel claims this was exactly what killed Arnold. + Samuel may have lied to Hiro about trapping Charlie somewhere else in time so Hiro would believe he has no chance of finding her without Samuel. - If Charlie is somewhere in the carnival, invisible, Hiro may accidentally run into her. - If she was hidden in the carnival, it is likely she would call out to Hiro, or at least try letting him know she's there, or that she's fine. • Maybe Teddy can cloak sound, too. - Arnold said, "No one deserves a fate like that..." (Bloodlines, Part 2), implying that he hid Charlie someplace dangerous. • He could betray Samuel and take Charlie to a safe place of his own choice.
Charlie will return when Glee is terminated.	None	+ The actress that plays Charlie, Jayma Mays, is on a Fox network non animated television program. Seeing Firefly, Dead Like Me, Wonderfalls and others lasted only two seasons; it is likely that Glee will do the same. Making the actress available to resume as Charlie Andrews. + Actors often move from television show to television show. Like Tessa Thompson and Kristen Bell from Veronica Mars to Heroes or Hayden Panettiere from Malcolm in the Middle to Heroes. Once Glee ends, Jayma could return. - Heroes may be terminated before Glee. • If this occurs, the cast of "Heroes" could join Jayma Mays. • Jayma Mays has been on Heroes, making her returning to Heroes likely. The entire cast of Heroes hasn't been on Glee, and the show will not likely need 30 new characters anytime soon, making that an unlikely situation. • Fox is rather notorious for canceling shows.
Charlie isn't trapped in time; Samuel simply disposed of her.	None	+ As long as Charlie is trapped somewhere in time, there is always the chance that Hiro may find a way to rescue her. If Samuel killed her, then he could continue stringing Hiro along indefinitely. + Now that Arnold is dead, Samuel has no method of sending Charlie food/water. - She could be "somewhere/somewhen" she has access to those. + Arnold said, "No one deserves a fate like that..." (Bloodlines, Part 2), implying that he hid Charlie someplace dangerous. • He could betray Samuel and take Charlie to a safe place of his own choice.