Theory:The Watcher

Main Article Theories about The Watcher Main Discussion

The following fan theories are about The Watcher.

For help on adding theories, see the help section.

Theories

Theory	Citations	Notes
The Watcher is Teddy.	None	+ Teddy and "The Watcher" wear similar clothing (hats and pink shirts) and have similar facial hair. + When Teddy made a cart disappear (Tabula Rasa), he did it in front of the ball toss game. The Watcher is the ball toss attendant. + Teddy's ability allows him to hide things. The Watcher mysteriously pops out of nowhere, perhaps being able to make himself disappear. - Teddy's ability appears similar to dimensional storage. That wouldn't explain how he could appear and disappear in literally the blink of an eye. + In chapter 7 of Slow Burn, the Watcher made Jennie Bowman inaudible and invisible. This seems like a possible application of cloaking. - Similar effects, different abilities. - They have different abilities. + Teddy could have manipulated Sylar's eyes to make it seem as though the cart disappeared. - Samuel would know if this wasn't Teddy's ability. + Teddy could have manipulated everyone into believing this was his ability. + Nothing suggests that Samuel does not know what Teddy's ability is. - The Watcher claims that every wept when they discovered he was gone but gradually accepted it. The carnies still know Teddy is around. + He never stated who wept for him. It could have been his family, at a time before he joined the carnival. - Aviv knowed Teddy, but he states the Watcher is not one of them.